Why Consistent Advertising Beats Everything:
The Science, The Data, and Why MyZipAds Works
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Why Consistent Advertising Works
The Science, The Studies, and Why MyZipAds Is Built on Proven Principles
Repetition & Visibility
​
Marketing has one core rule:
Visibility = survival.
Repetition = dominance.
Consistency = market share.
The businesses people remember are the ones they see often.
This is why:
• Empire Carpet’s number is still burned into everyone’s memory
• McDonald’s advertises daily even though everyone knows who they are
• Coca-Cola never stops spending, even with 100% awareness
Across every study and industry, the conclusion is the same:
People buy what’s familiar.
And familiarity only comes from repetition.
Why Most Direct Mail Fails
Direct mail does NOT fail because “mail doesn’t work.”
It fails because:
• Most mailers arrive inside envelopes
• Most mailers require opening or flipping through
• Homeowners throw the entire thing out sealed
• The ad never gets seen
• Zero visibility → zero chance
This is the “Opening Problem.”
And it’s why envelope books and coupon magazines die on arrival.
If it must be opened, it won’t be seen.
And if it’s not seen, it never existed.
Why Postcards Outperform Everything
Postcards solve every failure of traditional direct mail:
• No envelope
• No flipping pages
• No friction
• Instant visibility
• Even the throw-away moment counts
Worst case?
They toss it — but they still saw your name.
That is free brand building.
This is why postcards consistently outperform envelopes, magazines, and inserts in nearly every study.
And oversized postcards (like MyZipAds) have the highest visibility of all.
Why Monthly Advertising Beats
One-Off Ads
This is the part 99% of small businesses get wrong.
Advertising works only when it’s:
Repeated, consistent, and predictable.
One-off ads fail because:
• Attention fades fast
• People forget quickly
• Most consumers need 6–20 touchpoints before buying
Two or three mailers bring in temporary business.
But when you stop, memory resets and you start from zero again.
This is why businesses say:
“Advertising doesn’t work.”
when the real problem is:
They didn’t repeat it long enough for it to work.
MyZipAds solves this by making repetition affordable.
Social + Mail Reinforcement
The most effective marketing is multi-channel.
When a homeowner:
-
Sees you in their mailbox
-
Sees you on their phone
-
Sees you again via USPS Informed Delivery preview
The combined effect is massive.
It builds:
• Trust
• Familiarity
• Recognition
• Recall
• Response
This is why MyZipAds includes free social media videos, interviews, business spotlights, and monthly offer highlights.
It’s not “mail vs. online.”
It’s mail + online working together, which creates multiplication instead of addition.
The Studies
​
​
​
📌 Nielsen — Why Repetition Is Required for Results
Brands need multiple exposures (6–20 touchpoints) before consumers take action.
​
https://www.nielsen.com/insights/
​
​
​
📌 USPS Informed Delivery — Multi-Touch Boosts Engagement
Digital + physical preview dramatically increases brand recall and interaction.
​
https://www.usps.com/business/informed-delivery.htm
​
​
​
📌 Mere Exposure Effect — Psychology Study (PMC)
The brain trusts and prefers what it sees repeatedly — even briefly.
​
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6134073/
​
​
​
📌 Neuroscience Behind Direct Mail — PILMMA
Physical mail activates emotional processing areas of the brain more strongly than digital.
​
https://www.pilmma.org/blog/the-neuroscience-behind-direct-mail-campaigns/
​
​
​
📌 Nielsen Annual Marketing Report (Postalytics Summary)
Consumers trust traditional media more than digital — top performer: direct mail.
​
http://postalytics.com/blog/2025-nielsen-annual-marketing-report/
​
​
​
📌 Multi-Channel Marketing ROI — ROI Amplified
Brands combining mail + digital see up to 300% higher ROI.
​
https://roiamplified.com/insights/integrating-multiple-marketing-channels-effectively/
​
​
​
​
📌 Journal of Advertising Research: Cross-Media Advertising Synergy
​
https://www.journalofadvertisingresearch.com/content/54/4/392
​​​​​
What Just One New Customer Can Mean (Per Year)​
Consistent Visibility Builds Familiarity — and Familiarity Builds Trust
​​
Most local advertising fails for one simple reason:
people don’t see it often enough to remember it.
Unlike envelopes, emails, or magazines that require action, a postcard is seen automatically.
Even a brief glance creates awareness. Repeated monthly exposure builds familiarity.
Familiarity builds trust — and trust drives customer decisions.
That’s why MyZipAds focuses on consistent monthly visibility, not one-time promotions.
​
Every business is different.
The examples below are conservative illustrations, not guarantees.
For many local businesses, even one new customer relationship over the course of a year can more than justify the entire campaign.
Restaurants
One returning customer or household choosing your restaurant over time can represent $600–$1,500+ per year, depending on visit size and frequency.
Coffee Shops
One repeat customer over the year can generate $500–$1,200+ annually.
Bars, Lounges & Gaming Cafés
One loyal guest over time can generate $1,000–$3,000+ per year, depending on visits and spend.
Hair Salons & Barbers
One ongoing client relationship can be worth $800–$2,500+ per year.
Nail Salons, Med-Spas & Esthetics
One repeat client can generate $1,500–$4,000+ annually.
Dog Groomers & Pet Services
One recurring customer can be worth $700–$1,500 per year.
Auto Repair & Mechanics
One long-term customer relationship can generate $1,500–$4,000+ over time.
Landscaping & Lawn Care
One annual service agreement can range from $1,200–$4,000+ per year.
Pest Control
One ongoing service plan can generate $500–$1,200 annually.
Plumbers, HVAC & Electricians
One repeat customer relationship can be worth $1,000–$5,000+ per year.
Roofing, Siding & Gutters
One completed job can range from $3,000–$15,000+.
Kids Events, Party Rooms & Entertainment
One repeat family over time can generate $1,000–$3,000+ annually through bookings and referrals.
Realtors & Loan Officers
One closed transaction can mean $2,000–$15,000+ in commission.
Dentists & Chiropractic Practices
One ongoing patient relationship can represent $1,500–$4,000+ per year, depending on treatment and visit frequency.
Grocery Stores & Specialty Markets
One household that incorporates your store into their shopping habits — even partially — can represent $1,500–$4,000+ annually.
Auto Dealerships
One vehicle sale can represent $2,000–$8,000+ in gross profit, with additional long-term value from service, financing, and repeat business.
Liquor Stores / Wine & Spirits
One regular household can generate $1,200–$3,000+ per year, depending on frequency and basket size.
​
Gyms / Fitness Studios / Martial Arts
One retained member can represent $500–$3,000+ per year.
​
Dance Schools / Music Schools / Tutoring
One enrolled student can represent $1,200–$3,500+ annually, often with multi-year retention.
​
Daycares / Early Learning Centers
One enrolled child can represent $8,000–$15,000+ per year, depending on program type.
​
​
Banquet Halls / Event Venues
One event can represent $3,000–$10,000+, with additional long-term referral value.
​
Hotels (Local / Boutique / Event-Driven)
One booking relationship can generate $1,500–$5,000+ annually.
​
Storage Facilities / Self-Storage
One long-term customer can represent $1,200–$3,000+ over time.
​
Rental Spaces / Co-Working / Flex Offices
One long-term renter can generate $2,000–$6,000+ annually.
​
Financial Advisors / Insurance Agents
One client relationship can represent $1,000–$10,000+ in lifetime value.
​
Why Monthly Exposure Matters
Advertising works best when people see you consistently.
Continuous monthly exposure supports long-term customer acquisition rather than one-time spikes.
Over a 6–12 month period, familiarity and trust build — so when someone needs your service, your business is already top of mind.
For many businesses, that’s all it takes for the campaign to pay for itself.